- He was named All-American via Sporting News (second team) and PFF College (second team) in 2020.
- Invited to the NFLPA Collegiate Bowl. Neuzil finished career with 44 straight starts at left guard — every game after he moved to that position from being a backup center during the week of the ULM game in the ninth game of the 2017 season.
- Two-time first-team All-Sun Belt and three-time All-Sun Belt from PFF College.
- In his four seasons, App State ranked seventh (2020), 16th (2019), 14th (2018) and 22nd (2017) in rushing yards per game while ranking 40th (2020), 13th (2019), 21st (2018) and second (2017) in sacks allowed per game.