PLAYER OF THE YEAR | ALL-PRO | ALL-NFC | PRO BOWL SELECTIONS
| 1960-1969 | ||
|---|---|---|
| 1967 | Tommy Nobis, LB | (AP, 1st team) |
| 1970-1979 | ||
| 1971 | Claude Humphrey, DE | (NEA, 1st team) |
| 1972 | Claude Humphrey, DE | (AP, Pro Football Weekly, Football News, NEA, Football Digest, PFWA, 1st teams) |
| 1973 | Claude Humphrey, DE | (AP, Pro Football Weekly, PFWA, Football News, Computer Kickoff, 1st teams) |
| Nick Mick-Mayer, K | (Pro Football 1972 Weekly, 1st team) | |
| Mike Tilleman, DT | (National Star News Service, 1st team) | |
| 1974 | Claude Humphrey, DE | (NEA, 1st team) |
| Rolland Lawrence, DB | (AP, PFWA, 1st teams) | |
| 1980-1989 | ||
| 1980 | Mike Kenn, OT | (AP, PFWA, NEA, 1st teams) |
| 1981 | Alfred Jenkins, WR | (AP, PFWA, 1st teams) |
| 1982 | R.C. Thielemann, OG | (AP, CPFNW, 1st team) |
| Mike Kenn, OT | (CPFNW, 1st team; AP, NEA, 2nd team) | |
| William Andrews, RB | (AP, 2nd team) | |
| Jeff Van Note, C | (AP, 2nd team) | |
| Joel Williams, LB | (AP, 2nd team) | |
| 1983 | William Andrews, RB | (NEA, TSN, Football Digest 1st teams; CPFNW, 2nd team) |
| Billy Johnson, PR | (Pro Football Weekly, TSN, CPFNW, PFWA, Football Digest 1st teams; AP 2nd team) | |
| Mike Kenn, T | (Pro Football Weekly, 1st team; AP, CPFNW, 2nd teams) | |
| 1986 | Bill Fralic, G | (AP, NEA, Pro Football Weekly, Sporting News, 1st team) |
| 1987 | Bill Fralic | (AP, NEA, PFWA, Sporting News, 1st team) |
| Sylvester Stamps, KR | (Sporting News) | |
| 1988 | Bill Fralic, G | (Coll. & Pro FB Newsweekly, 1st team; AP, 2nd team) |
| Scott Case, FS | (AP, 2nd team) | |
| John Settle, RB | (Sports lllustrated) | |
| 1989 | Tony Casillas, DT | (AP, 2nd team) |
| Bill Fralic, G | (AP, 2nd team) | |
| 1990-1999 | ||
| 1990 | Andre Rison, WR | (AP, 1st team) |
| 1991 | Mike Kenn, OT | (AP, 1st team) |
| Andre Rison, WR | (AP, 2st team) | |
| Deion Sanders, CB | (AP, 2nd team) | |
| Jessie Tuggle, LB | (Sports Illustrated) | |
| 1992 | Deion Sanders, CB | (AP, 1st team, returner, AP, 2nd team, CB) |
| Andre Rison, WR | (AP, 2nd team) | |
| 1993 | Deion Sanders, CB | (AP, 1st team, CB) |
| Chris Hinton, OT | (AP 1st team) | |
| Andre Rison, WR | (AP, 2nd team) | |
| Norm Johnson, K | (AP, 2nd team) | |
| 1994 | Terance Mathis, WR | (AP, 2nd team) |
| 1998 | Jamal Anderson, RB | (AP, 1st team; Pro Football Weekly, 1st team) |
| Jessie Tuggle, LB | (AP, 2nd team) | |
| Ray Buchanan, CB | (AP, 2nd team) | |
| Jessie Tuggle, LB | (AP, 2nd team) | |
| 2000-PRESENT | ||
| 2000 | Darrick Vaughn, KR | (AP, 2nd team; College and Pro Football Weekly, 2nd team) |
| 2002 | Keith Brooking, LB | (College and Pro Football Weekly, Football Digest, 1st teams; AP, 2nd team) |
| 2004 | Keith Brooking, LB | (Football Digest, 1st team; AP, College and Pro Football Weekly, 2nd teams) |
| Alge Crumpler, TE | (Football Digest, 2nd team) | |
| Patrick Kerney, DE | (AP, College and Pro Football Weekly, Football Digest, 2nd teams) | |
| 2005 | Rod Coleman, DT | (AP, 2nd team) |